Capilano Honey CEO Ben McKee has failed to sign an affidavit declaring that the honey Capilano sells under its numerous brands is safe in an application by me to have Capilano’s defamation case against me summarily dismissed. Instead Capilano and Mr McKee have relied on an affidavit from their lawyer Richard Keegan, who has a history of perjury, and is full of hearsay evidence which carries little weight in court.
This is a follow-up post to last weeks article “Justice Lucy McCallum the judge helping Capilano dump their cheap Chinese Honey on Australian consumers” and outlines issues to be raised in the court hearing next Thursday (19/4/18) for my application to have Capilano’s and their CEO Ben McKee’s defamation case against me summarily dismissed.
No evidence that the honey is safe – No Capilano Honey employee will sign an affidavit
Capilano Honey have filed no direct evidence that their honey has been tested. It is only hearsay evidence supplied by their lawyer Richard Keegan. Capilano’s CEO Ben McKee and company secretary Annette Zbasnik are both mentioned in Richard Keegan’s affidavit as having spoken to Richard Keegan but neither filed and served an affidavit with any evidence.
It means no employee is prepared to sign an affidavit guaranteeing any claims about the quality of Capilano’s Honey which is disturbing and even more so when the CEO Ben McKee is one of the parties suing me for defamation.
Food and its quality is a huge public interest issue
The origin of food and its quality is a huge global issue and getting bigger as criminals enter the food industry with fake food and/or food of very poor quality trying to pass it off as higher quality food for a higher price. This was highlighted recently with a Netflix show called Rotten which focused on food fraud and also covered honey.
In November 2016 I emailed questions to the Australian Department of Agriculture and Water Resources (DAWR) asking questions about Capilano Honey and I wrote an article titled “Capilano Honey and Choice cover-up of poisonous honey exposed by Federal Government” that started off:
“The Australian Department of Agriculture and Water Resources (DAWR) has stated that it “is not aware of any herbicide testing of honey undertaken by Capilano” in response to questions that I emailed them. The statement totally discredits the false and misleading media releases that Capilano Honey has issued saying they extensively test their honey and denying allegations that Capilano sells poisonous and toxic honey.“
The questions I sent to DAWR in early November 2016 as per the above article and the other articles that I wrote forced Capilano Honey to make the below public statement regarding pesticides and honey which they only did via their website to cover themselves from any possible future legal action such as a consumer class action.
2016 Statement by Capilano Honey
Capilano Call For Reassessment of Neonicotinoid Use
While Capilano Honey has grown exponentially since 1953 the core values, established by founders J.C. (Tim) Smith MBE and his brother H.A. (Bert) Smith, of quality, innovation, safety and a true ‘hive to home’ experience continue to drive the company to this day.
It is because of these values that we feel dedicated to safeguarding the future of Australia’s bee population. Their welfare is of paramount importance to our daily operations and we are 100% committed to ensuring a sustainable future for honey supply and the 600 Aussie beekeeping families that we support across the country.
As a result, we continue to invest in a range of initiatives to promote bee health, effective biosecurity and to support beekeeper education. All of which will remain an ongoing priority for Capilano Honey.
In the late 1990’s, neonicotinoids came under increasing global scrutiny over their environmental impacts and have been linked to honey bee colony collapse disorder (CCD) in the USA. Subsequently, the European Union (EU) and several non EU countries have restricted or banned their use.
Increasingly, global research has indicated that neonicotinoids may be harmful to the health of honey bees. Capilano is committed to the health and wellbeing of Australia’s honey bees and, as such, does not endorse the use of neonicotinoids.
Following a government industry symposium on the matter, we are now certain that the registrations of neonicotinoids in Australia should be reviewed, reduced or removed entirely.
With this in mind, on the 1st November, 2016 we provided the Australian Pesticides and Veterinary Medicines Authority (APVMA) with a submission detailing some of the concerning scientific findings in relation to bees and their interactions with neonicotinoids in the environment. This submission forms part of the APVMA’s Roadmap for insect pollinator risk assessment in Australia.
While Australian farmers need to be able to manage their crops for maximised returns, the incorrect perception (and marketing) that neonicotinoids are completely harmless may be leading to their inappropriate overuse, particularly as a prophylactic treatment when pests aren’t even present.
We are now calling for extreme caution to be used when considering the use and regulation of neonicotinoids in Australia.
Capilano looks forward to further discussions with the APVMA on this issue on behalf of our beekeepers. In the interim, we will be working closely with The Australian Honey Bee Industry Council (AHBIC) who has commissioned further research on neonicotinoids and we will assist them in any actions resulting from the research findings.
I wrote another article not long after Capilano’s public statement titled: “Capilano Honey calls for ban on pesticides to stop poisoning bees and honey“.
In 2017 Capilano Honey put out another misleading statement as per below.
2017 Statement by Capilano Honey
In the October 2017 Capilano Honey published another statement on their website and Ben McKee said:
“Capilano Honey is aware of recent research indicating the presence of neonicotinoid pesticides in honey samples taken from across the globe.”
“Capilano is pleased to report that there have been no detections of any contaminants, including neonicotinoids or any other pesticide, in our 100% pure Australian honey.“ (Click here to see the statement on their website)
But Ben McKee makes no such statement in regards to their imported honey from China, Mexico, Argentina and other countries. McKee also doesn’t say what testing Capilano has done just that they have not detected any pesticides. Once again McKee and Capilano are playing smoke and mirrors and taking the reader for being a fool.
Smoke and mirrors
Capilano Honey say all the honey they sell in Australia under the Capilano Honey brand is Australian honey. That is quite possibly true but that is their standard line to any questioning and distorts the facts that Capilano Honey are the biggest Australian importers of foreign honey. Capilano sells tonnes of imported honey from China, Mexico, Argentina, Hungary and Brazil every year to Australian consumers via their other brands such as Allowrie, Smiths, Barnes and Wescobee.
Capilano also export their imported honey using the Capilano brand to countries like the Dubai, UAE and claim it is 100% Australian honey on the front of the bottles but put in fine print that it could be also imported honey. (Click here to read more)
So, when Capilano Honey talk about Capilano Honey being 100% Australian honey it is really a smoke and mirrors game they are playing. I even had to correct their barrister Sandy Dawson in court who lied and said that all Capilano branded honey is Australian honey which is a lie when you count exports.
Below are two videos that Capilano Honey don’t want you to see. There is nothing illegal about them or defamatory but Capilano Honey don’t want the public to know how much honey they import and that their contract beekeepers feed their bees imported irradiated Chinese pollen. Capilano took dodgy court action against Simon Mulvany and got a non-publication order so he can’t publish the below videos but that there’s no court order against me publishing them.
Capilano Honey lockout Simon Mulvany on their open day for Beekeepers – 17th of April 2016 Maryborough Victoria
“Capilano closed its doors to Save the bees Australia on their open day. Every year Capilano Honey invite beekeepers to meet in Maryborough Victoria, this is a tradition. This year contracted Capilano beekeepers insisted I attend. They warned me I would be appalled by the tonnes of imported honey Capilano hold on this premise. These beekeepers are honourable men and feel insulted that a company from such pure origins has turned into an Importing Mecca.”
The video below is Simon Mulvany showing the tonnes of imported honey at the Capilano factory in 2016.
Below is another video that was filmed at the open day where Simon Mulvany asks a beekeeper about the Chinese pollen that is fed to the bees.
The court case as per above is Thursday the 19th of April in the NSW Supreme Court with the matter name Capilano Honey & Ors v Shane Dowling. If you have free time show up and you can see yourself how corrupt the legal system is.
Please use the Twitter, Facebook and email etc. buttons below and help promote this post.
Kangaroo Court of Australia is an independent website and is reliant on donations to keep publishing. If you would like to support the continuance of this site, please click on the button below to donate via PayPal or go to the donations page for other donation options. (Click here to go to the Donations page)
If you would like to follow this website, you can by email notification at the top right of this page and about twice a week you will be notified when there is a new article.
Thank you for your support.
Categories: Capilano Honey