30 Comments on “The Spying Game versus The Lying Game. Australia’s new metadata retention laws”

  1. L u L u March 22, 2015 at 1:15 am #

    Yes sadly the political process that is proposed and ‘passed’ makes it more dangerous for whistle blowers. What needs to be looked at is who owns these new encryption sites and what the investment links are to the politicians who lead the parliamentary changes. It all looks more and more every day like the spying in book ‘1984’ book by George Orwell. and it is true that met-data collection and scanning has been happening for more than a decade, just as said and warned by Julian Assange. The issues is that some people have access and others do not. And it’s not happening in the interests of everyday Australian citizens.

    • Tony Hutton March 22, 2015 at 6:38 am #

      LuLu I have too agree with you, one of my concerns (be it founded or not) is that this Data Mining is not just used for Political Advantage of the Government of the Day (as Shane has described, in his article).

      But it is accessed or sold off to Major Corporations to spy on their smaller competitors, with their Intellectual Property and Company Secretes are stolen for Commercial Advantage and Profit… !!

      I am not as worried about the Average Citizen having their lives invaded, apart from there buying habits and potential commercial trends, there wouldn’t be much profit in it.. !!

      Its true that many of the Western Worlds Governments have squandered what credibility and trust they may have once enjoyed from their Citizens, once that is either being questioned, eroded or lost, its a 100 times harder to recover it (if it ever can be)… !!

      In reality the only thing that holds societies together over the long term is trust, a good example is that a Dollar is only Worth a Dollar, because of trust and when that trust is lost the currency collapses, it can and has historically happened overnight.. !!

  2. Gerrit Hendrik Schorel-Hlavka March 22, 2015 at 2:20 am #

    Too many laws and no common sense by politicians and in the process nothing is achieved other than robbing Australians of their rights.

  3. Tony Hutton March 22, 2015 at 2:46 am #

    It is amazing that within the USA the Obama Administration (Democrat/Labor) has persuade the same thing, as has the Abbott Government (Liberal/Republican) and there appears to be no difference between the two.. !!

    You cold say that Governments always have the one thing in common, they just love to Squander Money and on both sides of the house, only in different ways.. !!

    You could flip a coin on whether any Government is either Corrupt or Incompetent, with no matter if the coin lands on heads or tails both would be the correct answer.. 🙂

    • Paul March 23, 2015 at 9:57 pm #

      We are controlled from the District of Columbia, as indeed they are. This is the kind of lawmaking that comes from when a government is taking orders from its true Masters. There’ll be a reason for it, we just haven’t seen it yet. They have.

  4. Jo-Ann Markowski March 22, 2015 at 6:49 am #

    I made a phone call a few months ago to a business & this could have had serious legal implications for the business concerned because they were supposed to phone me & never did. The record of the phone call has disappeared from my itemised phone bill?! I rang the phone company & they just said that this was impossible. Who is to say that these records won’t be fiddled with to incriminate innocent people? How would you be able to prove that the data is correct?
    After waiting 4 hours in casualty to see a doctor on Sunday myself, a mother with a sick baby and another patient were told to go home without seeing anyone. This money should be spent on our hospitals etc. The fact that the two major parties are endorsing this shows just how rotten both of them are. Time to abandon both of them at the ballot box.

    • Con Dassos March 22, 2015 at 8:09 am #

      You’re right. Vote for the Wikileaks Party to make your vote mean something positive for the people of Australia.

  5. RANK FRANK March 22, 2015 at 11:14 am #

    If this provided info to prevent just one terrorist event in Australia it has succeeded.
    Quite frankly I have and will never have anything to hide.
    ‘ do not care if Government know what colour underpants I wear! ‘

  6. Jonde March 22, 2015 at 11:20 am #

    The situation is now way past the ‘servants’ running the ‘Manor House’, the servants live in luxury and the ‘owners’ are forced into sub-serviance with their accommodation ‘below stairs’
    Add to this, every word in every method of their communication will be ‘monitored’.

  7. Con Dassos March 22, 2015 at 12:21 pm #

    Hey FRANK RANK, can I have the keys to your car, front door, work office, credit cards, power of attorney and guardianship authority…… Remember you sad you have nothing to hide…. Come on Frank, be real. Terrorism it’s almost synonymous with false flags, it’s called psychology and it’s real, real, real..
    My only concern with your comment, with respecting your point of view is that “you can’t wake someone up who is pretending to be asleep”…

    • RANK FRANK March 22, 2015 at 12:56 pm #

      You obviously support protecting terrorism . Any info to prevent crime is good. I cannot see Australia run by the Stazzi. You are a closet protector of evil. An open society should not fear. Simply alarmism just try to do something positive – any
      Initiative is constantly bagged by those that propagate negativity.

      • Robert March 23, 2015 at 5:42 pm #

        Germany tried metatdata retention laws and concluded they don’t work.

  8. Con Dassos March 22, 2015 at 2:45 pm #

    Interesting opinion Frank. Please answer my questions if you’re game to expose your ideology.
    I do not support terrorism-as you charge. Very defamatory statement Frank.
    Your understanding of “doing something positive”, I suspect is based upon what you believe is necessary, fair enough, but please consider very carefully the value of false flags which can influence your objectivity and consequently create fear. Your fear. Please read about all the historical false flags throughout history that lead to WW2, Vietnam war, Korean war, Iraq war (1 & 2) and the almost successfully invasion of Syria but the U.S. Military that was only stopped when Russia simply parked their navy of the Syrian coast last year (not a bullet fired), just standing up to bullies.
    I don’t propagate negativity, just asking you to think for yourself. And please don’t let the fear propagated by the mainstream media affect you…..now they ARE evil…. Go read the “Flat Earth News”…..only if your game to know the truth!


    • RANK FRANK March 22, 2015 at 8:45 pm #

      Sorry Con . You are obviously a very good bloke and a great Australian.
      But you are unfortunately an Ostrich . We need every possible tool to fight terror.
      Anything else is unAusraliaian. We protect our own.
      ps – do not hide behind a smoke screen . Nothing is perfect . Only God is perfect.

    • Concerned Aussie March 23, 2015 at 1:44 pm #


      it is a slow and tedious process to wade through the mud of disinformation. it takes years of research, determination and analysis. bit by bit one can break down virtually every thing they tell us on the controlled media as being a gross lie, manipulating us towards a certain nefarious agenda. very few people have the time and inclination to verify what we’re told – and that’s why very few people can see what is really going on. but eventually those who make the effort break free from the thought control matrix these criminals have created for us. (they own the MSM too, remember?) more and more people are doing just that, and now we are a serious threat to their way of life – their lucrative criminal enterprises are in jeopardy. THIS IS THE REASON WHY THEY NEED TO TIGHTEN THEIR CONTROL OF THE INTERNET, and in a way that the masses do not know what they are really doing. convince the people you are “saving” them, and they will gladly submit to whatever they ask.

      but i say all this for the benefit of anyone else who reads this, because i can see that you know that already.

  9. Allan Usherwood March 23, 2015 at 1:38 am #

    I tend to agree with Rank Frank, I have nothing to hide they can read my mail anytime.

    • wgirling March 23, 2015 at 8:33 am #

      and mine

  10. Concerned Aussie March 23, 2015 at 1:05 pm #

    These laws do NOTHING to protect Australia from this scam called “terrorism”. The world is waking up to the massive deception and criminal activities being undertaken by all of them from the top down – this site is just one tiny example of the crimes being committed. These laws are designed to harass and silence anyone who speaks out about it, and to slowly start shutting down websites that expose the truth.

    the internet is possibly THE biggest threat to these criminals. they do not want people to find out what they are doing, so shutting down the independent news sites, bloggers and their readers/commenters is their primary goal. these laws are just the first step to achieving that.

  11. uloola March 23, 2015 at 7:37 pm #

    The foot is now in the door,the gap will get wider.If the federal government have nothing to hide then establish a federal I.C.A.C.This way we can see who the pollies are communicating with .After all we are all equal under the law.

    • Jo-Ann Markowski March 23, 2015 at 9:20 pm #

      I totally agree. There is no ICAC for the A.C.T. and there should be. The corruption that goes on there is over the top, I am dealing with it at the moment and they think they can do what they like because they have no one to answer to. If they want to examine every ones correspondence etc then we should be able to examine theirs. The A.C.T. think they are like the Vatican state or the City of London and they should be answerable to an ICAC like the other states!

      • uloola March 24, 2015 at 2:47 am #

        If,after the next election the federal government has a docile senate then we may see the Australian version of the Patriot Act.

  12. Con Dassos March 23, 2015 at 9:20 pm #

    Concerned Aussie is right on the ball.
    That is why not one rational argument has been provided by those who “have nothing to hide”. Usually it’s because they have everything to hide, and their histrionic descriptions are nothing more than theatre (comic theatre at that) to scare and intimidate….they fail.
    Suggestion- Shane you need a window where members (bona fide only) can vote on a question you pose…..would be very interesting!

  13. L u L u March 24, 2015 at 12:14 am #

    Look, the issue is that the government can watch everyone from afar and also what we type in the privacy of our private emails to each other, and to government. The people really already have little scope to scrutinize government or call for transparency.
    I have heard and have experienced what Jo-Ann says about a call disappearing. I had a very rude moving text image sent to me from one of my police mates in about 2002. The men were laughing their heads off at my frustration that the ‘evidence’ went when I terminated the incoming message, yet it was there when I was annoyed at it and showed it to my (ex) boss, the sender. He is a mate of … that lot.
    Apologies for the long post. But what i have to say is important, relevant and reliable. The changes being made impact us all far more than we currently can immediately perceive.
    Yes, there is much more to this ‘communications’ watching thingo than we are told. I know. I heard and saw what USA staff said in 2002, but I am not allowed to say for another two years … except it is not in favour of the Commonwealth.
    There is so much advancement already done within government channels. The OZ military and policing activity is decades ahead of what gets released to the public.
    In 2005 I personally heard of an agenda that I find very worrying and see unfolding, despite my efforts help the people. What I was told was very anti-democracy, anti-Australian. It was an ‘elite’ v’s us attitude. The 1984 book describes the proposed outcome.

    (Moderator: rest deleted as way too long)

  14. Con Dassos March 24, 2015 at 11:13 pm #

    Hey Lu Lu, we are already scrutinizing government and calling for transparency from the day Wikileaks put “Collateral Murder” on line worldwide and we learnt about the leaks to the US Embassy in Canberra by our ‘elected’ politicians… Don’t you know about this. Why don’t you know ?
    And then Snowden exposes to the world how treacherous and deceitful the “Five Eyes are”….. You know: USA, UK, New Zealand,Canada & (yes your right,) A.u.s.t.r.a.l.i.a.

    As the evil, lethal and anti- human Joseph Goebbels (Adolf Hitler’s Reich Minister of Propaganda) boasted in the 1940’s:

    “If you tell a lie big enough and keep repeating it, people will eventually come to believe it. The lie can be maintained only for such time as the State can shield the people from the political, economic and/or military consequences of the lie. It thus becomes vitally important for the State to use all of its powers to repress dissent, for the truth is the mortal enemy of the lie, and thus by extension, the truth is the greatest enemy of the State.”

    The truth IS the mortal enemy of the state– we DO have the strength to expose the truth and we must all keep doing it, always.

  15. L u L u March 25, 2015 at 1:23 am #

    were you trying to typing the new name of this good nation
    as perhaps the great new world of southern
    ‘Cross’ Au IStRA(e)Liar?
    What happened overseas was very terrible and is unwanted here.
    See if your local library has the book ‘Hawke P.M’ ISBN: 0 207 14806 6
    published 1979 and again in 1983, by John Hurst.
    At least those printed pages cannot be altered to hide content
    (there are detailed events & names depicting a certain agenda from one cultural group).
    It is really laid out on those pages who and how a certain group gained dominance and why, and who they consulted from certain communist nations.
    I see the C.P.A. set (especially detailed in that book) still running their tactics.

    • Con Dassos May 9, 2015 at 12:47 pm #

      Hi Lulu,

      I found the book “Hawker PM”, very cheap at $9.95, read it cover to cover and not found the reference re ” a certain group gained dominance”.
      Can you please give me a page reference ( if it exists).

      By the way just to help you and Rank Frank, just have a look (todays ABC Breaking News) at:


      Really sorry it highlights your mislead beliefs and values, but then, that’s what happens with tribe mentality.

      Wake up! Stand up! Be honest! Nothing else is acceptable in Australia !

      And to our Government…. I’m watching YOU!

  16. Friendly Advise March 26, 2015 at 4:59 pm #

    Rank Frank have you ever thought of how many ways metadata can be used to benefit those who can access it. From what I can gather you only seem to look at it from one perspective.You are right in saying it can benefit government agencies in the cause to stop terrorism or criminal activities. What about all the other numerous possibilities which can arise from giving a selected few access to such personal information.

  17. Gimp4930 March 27, 2015 at 6:03 pm #

    I wonder if turnbull has shares or owns a VPN company?

  18. Harquebus July 8, 2015 at 10:43 am #

    Hope some find this useful.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s